Dotcom, subprime, AI, oh my…

Photo by Jp Valery on Unsplash
On the experience of living through a major financial crisis
In the past I may have worried about dating myself and thereby becoming unemployable in an industry that favors youth above all else, but with the recent strong preference for (ignorable) expertise,[1] perhaps that's no longer a concern.
I graduated with a master's degree in urban planning in 2007. I collect no analytics on this site, so I have no hard data on who my readers are, but I suspect some of you don't have the same visceral reaction to that year that people my age might. It's been almost 20 years since the financial crisis that began that year led to the Great Recession. Today the Financial Times published (paywall) a piece titled ECB says AI borrowing has 'parallels' with subprime bubble. You can read the original ECB report here. It states in part (emphasis mine):
“Big tech firms are estimated to have total off-balance-sheet commitments of more than $4tn as of the second quarter of 2026,” the report said, adding that this was “well in excess” of on-balance-sheet liabilities. The ECB said that it saw “historical parallels with the dotcom and subprime bubbles” and the risk of “spillovers” affecting euro area financial stability.
...
Circular deals within the tech sector add to the “opaqueness” of AI-related debt, the ECB argued in the report, highlighting that cloud service providers and AI labs borrow from chip manufacturers to buy their products in deals that “inflate the expected revenues” of both sides.
“Even if AI as a technology successfully transforms the global economy, the credit-driven AI boom may result in overcapacity, capital misallocation and credit losses for investors,” the ECB warned.
The housing collapse had a profound influence on my life. It turns out that jobs in urban planning are predicated upon a functioning real estate industry. I might argue that this shouldn't be the case, but we live in Dumb Times, so it is. Peers who had graduated before me lost their good jobs and sank into depression—including the Suma cum laude of my class, who after being laid off took employment at her family's restaurant business as a hostess. I was unable to find work for six months and was forced to live in my in-laws' basement. When I did get a job, it was a glorified internship for a small township in Pennsylvania, with no benefits whatsoever and that paid under $35,000; I held that job for three years, as it was the only thing available. I graduated with $50,000 in student loan debt.
Anyone who understands how compound interest works knows the damage that accrues from such a poor start. Not only was it a decade before I paid off my loans, it was over a decade before I had any form of retirement savings. Even now I'm well behind peers who had a better start earlier in life.
Honestly, the only reason I was able to attain financial stability was teaching myself Java and transitioning into software development. This was something I did essentially on a lark, because I enjoyed it. Bonus points that it paid well.[2] It's likely that transition may never have happened, if not for the world-changing subprime crisis and the Great Recession that followed. In a very real way, I owe my present life, for better or worse, to that uncontrollable global moment.
So it is with both a profound sadness and a very physical sense of alarm that I watch the world do this again, only "bigger and better" this time. Apparently we're doomed to have a new financial crisis every 10-20 years. Even if AI has successes, its circular financing model that inflates revenues, and its massive off-balance-sheet debt, carries very high risk of another collapse.[3] I'm not sure we can "too big to fail" ourselves out of this one.
I searched for "software industry not hiring juniors" and found so many sources. I think most are AI-generated which is why I'm not linking any here. But if you're reading this blog, you're already aware of the problem. ↩︎
I can honestly say I had no idea it would pay as well as it has over the years. I was then and remain now a proud Luddite. (That is, a highly skilled worker "who protested against the usage of certain types of automated machinery owing to their concerns over worker pay, labour savings, child labour, working conditions, and output quality.") ↩︎
This isn't even to mention that its stated primary use-case is putting us all out of work. ↩︎
- ← Previous
How to lose a friend